Lithium complex vs calcium sulfonate vs polyurea grease
Short answer: Lithium complex is the all-around workhorse for general bearings and equipment. Calcium sulfonate is the pick for wet, salty, heavily loaded or washdown conditions because of its strong water resistance and built-in rust and load protection. Polyurea is the go-to for electric motor bearings and long-life, sealed or high-speed applications. Check compatibility before switching, because some pairs don't mix well.
Why the thickener matters
Grease is mostly base oil, held in place by a thickener. The thickener sets how the grease handles heat, water, load, pumping and mixing. The NLGI grade, covered in NLGI grades explained, only tells you how firm it is.
Side by side
| Lithium complex | Calcium sulfonate | Polyurea | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best at | General purpose, wide temperature range | Water resistance, rust protection, heavy and shock loads | Long life in electric motors and high-speed bearings |
| Water resistance | Good | Excellent | Good |
| High-temperature life | Good | Very good | Very good |
| Built-in load and rust protection | From additives | Inherent | From additives |
| Watch out for | Washout in very wet service | Can be stiffer in cold, auto-lube systems need a check | Compatibility with other thickeners |
| Typical uses | Plant bearings, trucks, equipment chassis | Excavator pins, plow trucks, quarries, paper and steel mills, food washdown (H1 versions) | Electric motors, fans, sealed-for-life bearings |
Lithium complex: the default
If a plant or shop stocks one grease, it's usually an NLGI 2 lithium complex. It handles a wide temperature range, pumps well and works in most bearings. Mobilgrease XHP is a common example, and Mobilith SHC is its synthetic counterpart for extreme temperatures or long intervals.
Calcium sulfonate: when water and salt are the problem
Calcium sulfonate greases resist water washout and corrosion very well and carry heavy and shock loads without extra EP additives. That makes them a strong choice for equipment on salted Pennsylvania roads, quarry and aggregate equipment, washdown areas and anything that sits wet. Check pumpability before using one in an auto-lube system in winter.
Polyurea: the electric motor grease
Polyurea greases are known for long life at high temperature and speed, which is why many electric motor manufacturers use them. Mobil Polyrex EM is a common example. Over-greasing motors is a bigger risk than under-greasing, so follow the motor maker's amounts and intervals.
Mixing greases: be careful
When two thickeners mix in a bearing, the blend can soften and run out, or harden. Published compatibility charts list many pairs as borderline or incompatible, and polyurea in particular varies by formulation. When you switch:
- Confirm compatibility with your supplier.
- Purge the old grease until the new grease shows at the seal or relief.
- Shorten the next interval or two to flush out any leftovers.
- Label the fitting with the new product.