API CK-4 vs FA-4: which diesel oil is right for your fleet?

By Josh Malczak · Fleet & Construction · Published 2026-11-08

Short answer: API CK-4 is the safe, backward-compatible choice for almost every diesel engine, on-road and off-road, old and new. API FA-4 is a thinner, fuel-saving oil for specific newer on-highway engines (generally 2017 and later) whose manufacturer approves it. It is not backward compatible. If you run a mixed fleet or any off-road equipment, CK-4 is the one oil that covers everything.

Why there are two categories

API introduced both categories in December 2016 to replace CJ-4. Engine makers wanted better protection against oxidation, aeration and shear in modern high-pressure engines, and some also wanted thinner oils to help meet greenhouse gas and fuel economy rules. One category couldn't do both, so API split it.

The key difference: HTHS viscosity

High-temperature high-shear (HTHS) viscosity measures how thick the oil stays under the heat and shear inside bearings and on cylinder walls.

API CK-4API FA-4
HTHS viscosity3.5 cP minimum2.9–3.2 cP
Common grades15W-40, 10W-30, 5W-4010W-30, 5W-30
Backward compatibleYes, replaces CJ-4, CI-4 and olderNo
Use inNearly all diesel enginesOnly engines the OEM approves for FA-4
Main benefitBroad protection and durabilityFuel economy

When FA-4 makes sense

When to stick with CK-4

How to check your engines

Look in each operator's manual or the OEM's current oil spec. The specs to look for include Detroit DFS 93K222 (CK-4) and DFS 93K223 (FA-4), Cummins CES 20086 (CK-4) and CES 20087 (FA-4), and Volvo VDS-4.5 and Mack EOS-4.5 (CK-4), and Volvo VDS-5 and Mack EOS-5 (FA-4). If the engine doesn't list an FA-4 approval, don't use FA-4.

Product examples

In the Mobil line, Mobil Delvac 1300 Super 15W-40 and 10W-30 are CK-4 oils, and Mobil Delvac 1 LE 5W-30 is an FA-4 oil. I'll match the right one to each unit in your fleet.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use CK-4 in an engine that calls for FA-4?
Yes. CK-4 is generally acceptable where FA-4 is allowed, though you give up the fuel-economy benefit. Check the OEM spec.
Can I use FA-4 in an older engine?
No. FA-4 isn't backward compatible, and older engines need the higher HTHS of CK-4.
Is 15W-40 CK-4 still OK?
Yes. 15W-40 CK-4 remains the workhorse for mixed and off-road fleets.

Information here is general guidance. Always check your equipment manufacturer's recommendations and warranty terms.

Free download: PA Plant Lubrication Checklist

A one-page walk-through checklist for maintenance teams: storage, contamination, labeling, oil analysis and winter readiness.

Download the checklist (PDF)

Want a second set of eyes on your lubrication?

Tell me what you run and what's giving you trouble. I'll come out, walk the equipment, and give you a straight answer on what would help, whether or not you end up buying anything.

Request a lubrication review Call 724-406-9524