API CK-4 vs FA-4: which diesel oil is right for your fleet?
Short answer: API CK-4 is the safe, backward-compatible choice for almost every diesel engine, on-road and off-road, old and new. API FA-4 is a thinner, fuel-saving oil for specific newer on-highway engines (generally 2017 and later) whose manufacturer approves it. It is not backward compatible. If you run a mixed fleet or any off-road equipment, CK-4 is the one oil that covers everything.
Why there are two categories
API introduced both categories in December 2016 to replace CJ-4. Engine makers wanted better protection against oxidation, aeration and shear in modern high-pressure engines, and some also wanted thinner oils to help meet greenhouse gas and fuel economy rules. One category couldn't do both, so API split it.
The key difference: HTHS viscosity
High-temperature high-shear (HTHS) viscosity measures how thick the oil stays under the heat and shear inside bearings and on cylinder walls.
| API CK-4 | API FA-4 | |
|---|---|---|
| HTHS viscosity | 3.5 cP minimum | 2.9–3.2 cP |
| Common grades | 15W-40, 10W-30, 5W-40 | 10W-30, 5W-30 |
| Backward compatible | Yes, replaces CJ-4, CI-4 and older | No |
| Use in | Nearly all diesel engines | Only engines the OEM approves for FA-4 |
| Main benefit | Broad protection and durability | Fuel economy |
When FA-4 makes sense
- Your fleet is mostly late-model on-highway trucks whose engine maker approves FA-4.
- Fuel is a big line item, and even a small efficiency gain matters across your miles.
- You can keep FA-4 out of every engine that isn't approved for it.
When to stick with CK-4
- Mixed fleets with older trucks, pickups, or construction and ag equipment.
- Any off-road equipment. Most off-road engine makers call for CK-4-type oils.
- Shops where one oil for everything matters more than a small fuel gain. Wrong-oil mistakes are a real risk when two diesel oils sit side by side.
How to check your engines
Look in each operator's manual or the OEM's current oil spec. The specs to look for include Detroit DFS 93K222 (CK-4) and DFS 93K223 (FA-4), Cummins CES 20086 (CK-4) and CES 20087 (FA-4), and Volvo VDS-4.5 and Mack EOS-4.5 (CK-4), and Volvo VDS-5 and Mack EOS-5 (FA-4). If the engine doesn't list an FA-4 approval, don't use FA-4.
Product examples
In the Mobil line, Mobil Delvac 1300 Super 15W-40 and 10W-30 are CK-4 oils, and Mobil Delvac 1 LE 5W-30 is an FA-4 oil. I'll match the right one to each unit in your fleet.